By the ElonMek technical team · Troubleshooting · Published 2026-10-14

When holes, spots or unstable sizing show up on the paper, the defoamer is the usual first suspect, because it is the additive everyone knows is in the wet end. Often the real cause sits somewhere else entirely, and the mill spends weeks changing a product that was never guilty.
The way out is to separate the defects a defoamer genuinely causes from the ones it merely gets blamed for, then trace the specific case with evidence.
Defects a Defoamer Really Does Cause
Silicone spots and fish-eyes
Silicone defoamers break foam fast, but silicone oil carried into the system with the white water can set as clear specks on the sheet, which turn into fish-eyes after coating. White cardboard and specialty papers are the most exposed grades.
Sizing loss
Over-dosed defoamer leaves hydrophilic components on the fibre surface. In AKD or ASA sizing systems the defoamer competes with the sizing agent for adsorption sites, Cobb values climb and print-through follows.
Adhering deposits
Emulsion defoamers can thicken and precipitate during storage. The deposits stick to forming wires, press felts and pipeline walls, then break loose and land on the finished sheet as oil spots.
Defects That Only Look Like the Defoamer
Defects caused by foam itself
Micro-bubbles entrained in the pulp, not the foam floating on top, are what spoils formation. A defoamer acts on surface foam and cannot remove air trapped inside the stock. The sources are pulp-tank agitation, air drawn in at pump seals and white-water circulation. The fix is degassing and process work, not more chemical.
Sizing problems from process fluctuation
Weak sizing can come from the pulp formulation, pH, the drying profile or the sizing agent quality. The defoamer is only one component in the white-water system, and alcohol-based defoamers interfere with sizing the least when the system is sensitive.
Pinholes from dissolved gas
As the stock flows from headbox to vacuum boxes, the sharp pressure drop releases dissolved gas, and the escaping bubbles leave pinholes. This is a molecular-level phenomenon and has nothing to do with the defoamer.
Resin and slime deposits
Resins and fatty acids leached from the raw stock, waste-paper pulp in particular, together with slime grown inside the system, deposit on the wire section and produce spots and holes. Unlike silicone spots, these respond to system cleaning and biocide programmes.
A Short Tracing Routine That Settles the Question
- Look at the pattern. Regularly distributed spots point towards defoamer residue; random, irregular flaws are more often foam, resin or a detached deposit.
- Check the timing. Defects appearing right after a batch switch or a dose adjustment implicate the defoamer. Defects that ease after a system cleaning and then build again point towards accumulating contamination.
- Run a gradient test. Step the defoamer dose down and watch the defect trend. If the defects improve as the dose falls, the defoamer is very likely responsible; if there is no correlation, move the investigation to the foam sources.
Choosing a Grade That Keeps the Sheet Clean
- Match the chemistry to the section. In the pulping stage, silicone defoamers are an efficient choice for rapid knockdown. In the forming section of high-surface-quality grades such as white cardboard and base coating paper, silicone-free or low-residue grades are the safer call.
- Mind the sizing system. For sized-paper production, alcohol-based or polyether-based defoamers interfere least with the sizing degree.
- Feed it where the foam is born. Dose upstream of the foam-generating zone so the product has time to disperse evenly through the stock.
- Keep the dose honest. Most defoamer-related defects trace back to over-dosing. Typical consumption runs 100 to 500 g per tonne of paper; confirm the exact working dose with on-site trials.
